Washington, Nov 20: US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) paid an estimated $13 million every month for detention beds that remained unused at four facilities, raising concerns over the agency’s spending decisions and the cost-effectiveness of its expanding detention infrastructure, according to a federal audit.
Representational Image
The Government Accountability Office (GAO) found that an average of 9,733 beds covered by the agency’s payment commitments remained vacant each day during the period examined.
The four facilities included in the monthly cost estimate were California City Correctional Facility, North Lake Correctional Facility, Folkston D. Ray Processing Center and Diamondback Correctional Center.
Diamondback accounted for approximately $5.84 million in monthly payments, while California City received around $5.02 million. The GAO calculation included facility-wide charges along with applicable daily bed rates.
The audit noted that guaranteed payments can help ICE secure detention capacity quickly and protect facility operators against financial losses. However, such arrangements can also leave the government paying substantial amounts for space that is not being used.
Questions Over Billions Spent on Detention Infrastructure
The watchdog also raised concerns over ICE’s property acquisition programme, following Congress’s allocation of $45 billion for immigration detention in July 2025.
ICE purchased 11 warehouse properties for approximately $1.07 billion before significantly scaling back plans to convert them into detention facilities. The agency now intends to sell seven of those properties.
In a separate move, ICE acquired four existing detention facilities for approximately $2.2 billion in July and August 2026. However, the GAO said the scope, timeline and estimated costs of further acquisitions remained uncertain.
The audit found that ICE had not revised its spending plan to adequately reflect the changes in its acquisition programme. It also had not sufficiently assessed the full lifecycle costs of its investments.
Shortage of Staff Adds to Oversight Concerns
The GAO also pointed to gaps in staffing responsible for monitoring detention facilities and validating invoices.
ICE was working to fill 55 of the 87 positions allocated for facility oversight and payment verification, indicating a shortage of personnel tasked with monitoring expenditure and operations.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) agreed with the GAO’s two recommendations, which called for complete and timely spending plans, comprehensive estimates of lifetime costs and consideration of alternative options before major detention investments are approved.
However, DHS asked the watchdog to close the recommendation concerning spending plans, arguing that the relevant documents had already been prepared, approved and updated in line with ICE guidelines.
The GAO rejected the request, noting that a spending plan submitted in July continued to project more than $38 billion in fiscal 2026 obligations, despite significant changes to the warehouse conversion programme.
ICE ultimately reported approximately $10 billion in obligations from the detention allocation by the end of the fiscal year.
Both GAO recommendations remain open. DHS said ICE would work with the department’s management directorate to establish a standard process for evaluating future investments.
Senator Calls for Greater Accountability
The audit has also triggered criticism from Democratic lawmakers. Senator Dick Durbin, the senior Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee and one of the lawmakers who requested the review, said the findings highlighted waste in the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement programme.
Calling for greater accountability, Durbin said DHS and ICE should be held responsible for their spending decisions.
He also pointed to the costly warehouse acquisitions and staffing shortages in detention oversight as reasons for stronger congressional scrutiny.
The GAO findings focus on improving financial planning, evaluating long-term costs and strengthening oversight before additional public money is committed to detention infrastructure.